This phrase came to mind as I was running out to help Tricia unload groceries from the car a little while ago. We had spent the morning, once again, shoveling snow (I even had to get out the pickaxe to take out a rather hefty mound of frozen effluence in the driveway left by the snow plows, but this is a double digression) so the walkway to the car was clear and smooth.
Well, I figur’d no need put’n on my boots, the slippers will do just fine. On the way back to the house as I was descending the steps, I quickly found out that sans snow, the sidewalk took on an invisible glaze of ice. As I picked myself up off at the bottom of the steps, Tricia was coming up behind me. I prepared myself for expressions of concern. That’s not what I got. Rather, Tricia opined “I guess that’s why they call them slippers.” Somehow the fall hurt much worse after that.
Expressions of love, or the lack thereof, have a significant influence on the way one experiences life’s ups and downs. Perhaps this recognition might be what is behind a rather pernicious error that affects all too many priests today. If you are listening to a homily on just about any Gospel reading in which Jesus is confronting the Pharisees, as soon as you hear the priest recite the number of laws the Pharisees formulated you can guess what is coming next. Usually, this is counter-posed with Jesus’ “reduction” of the law to “love”; that is, love of God and neighbor. This observation is quickly followed up with a comparison to the number of canons in current Canon Law. What one is then invited to draw from this that the Church has obviously missed Jesus’ message and we have devolved back into a bunch of Pharisees. After all, all we need is love.
These homilists miss the irony that they in fact suffer from the same juridicism that afflicted the Pharisees. Love is the foundation of law but I suppose that part of their problem is a mistaken notion of love. All too often for modern Pharisees, love is replaced with a false sentimentalism in which you are simply supposed to try to force yourself to have “good feelings” about others. If you can have these good feelings, then nothing else is required. We are left with an emotivist type of morality. However, these emotivist Pharisees inconsistently transition to a natural law morality when it suits them, usually when it has to do with someone’s “rights.” When it comes to “rights,” is seems obvious to them that everyone must be able to recognize that this is a God given law.
Legal positivists/jurdicists also have a mistaken notion of reality. Love is not an emotion, but an ontological reality. God is Love. Therefore, human love, which is a participation in Trinitarian love has a structure to it that one cannot change. Love is authentic only when it is grounded in truth. God has created the cosmos in accord with this truth. Thus, divine law and natural law are not postivist impositions of God’s arbitrary will; much less human created restrictions on human freedom. They are roadmaps to a happy, fulfilled life.
One cannot authentically love his neighbor while turning a blind eye to his sins or even worse, encouraging him to behave in self destructive and socially destructive ways. For example, embracing the sexual dysfunction of others because they claim it makes them happy may be a source of mutual good feelings, but it is not love.
Human love exists because of Trinitarian love. Human love reaches its fullness in disinterested self-gift. This means that we desire the other’s good for his own sake. While making him feel good about himself, and ourselves, is nice, “good feelings” is not an end. The other’s authentic happiness and personal fulfillment in holiness is the only authentic, ultimate end for anyone. In order to achieve this he needs to know the truth about God, about himself, and about how he must deal with various situations in order to authentically fulfill himself.
Love is also an act of the will. It is possible because we have the freedom to choose…to choose excellence that is, not the freedom to choose indifferently. That is why Jesus told us that only those who do the Father’s will authentically love Him.
Therefore, in order to achieve authentic happiness and fulfillment, we require more than an easily mistaken, general phrase for our guidance. This necessary, more detailed guidance is what the Catholic Church provides us. We are given true freedom to live as God calls us to live because the Church unhesitatingly teaches us what is in accord with authentic love and what is not, in the various situations of life which we face. Canon law and the moral teachings form part of this teaching.
In the end, it is true that all you need is love but one must recognize what love really is and all that comes with it.